Thanks, Robyn, for this thought-provoking question: How are you addressing religion in your family? Are you planning on raising the girls Jewish or otherwise?
I thought about my answer to this question and then consulted Marcia and decided my thoughts and her thoughts may not be entirely in sync. Nevertheless -- I will share. It's an issue that we are working out as we go along.
A bit of background. I'm Jewish and was raised in a small town in the bible belt. My family was the only Jewish family there. We belonged to a synagogue over an hour away and attended a Jewish summer camp (where Robyn and I met). Marcia was raised as a protestant. Not only is she a PK (preacher's kid) but both her parents are PKs too. Both families have lots of preachers and other devout Christians. Eventually her dad became one of the top leaders in his church. Organized religion was a major structural element of her childhood. It is interesting that neither she nor her siblings participate in religion any more.
Back to the answer. Our original plan was rather vague but vague in a way that seemed okay to me. Marcia and I decided to create a family life built around rituals that draw from a number of different traditions--Jewish, Christian, and other ones.
We wanted the kids to have meaningful memories that centered on rituals that are based on family activities. For example, I love the way the Passover Seder reminds me of all the other past Seders that I have enjoyed. When I was in grad school, my friend Susan D invited everyone she knew, regardless of religious preference, to a huge Seder. We all sat on the floor and brought our own plate and silverware. We would read the passover story with the feminist haggadah, and those of us who were Jewish (less than 10%) would do the Hebrew passages. Susan's interpretation of the holiday helped me understand the universal appeal of this story of deliverance. Since Susan moved away from Houston, I have tried to recreate her Seder, although on a smaller scale.
Rituals tend to remind of us the past and provide markers for our memories. In our family, we have our own haggadah that we have spliced together over the years. This past year we celebrated Hanukkah and Christmas. We have been lighting candles on Friday night for Shabbat. We dyed eggs for Easter, and we plan to add more of these traditions as the girls are able to do more. This may sound like a mish mash, but it doesn't bother me. So far. (On the hospital form, Marcia labeled herself Unitarian!)
We haven't participated in organized religion of any kind. This morning I told Marcia I had no interest in joining a religious institution and asked if she felt the same. She said she was not so sure lately. So, as you can see, we have more to discuss.
I would love to hear how you are dealing with these decisions, or how you think you would, when the situation arises.
Recent Comments